In May 2026, the Integrative Health Policy Consortium urged federal policymakers to distinguish student-loan repayment performance from early-career earnings and to recognize the distinctive pathways of licensed health professions. With final rules now in place, implementation underway, and litigation reshaping portions of the regulatory landscape, IHPC examines where those concerns stand today—and what comes next.
In May 2026, the Integrative Health Policy Consortium (IHPC) submitted supplemental comments to the U.S. Department of Education addressing proposed changes to federal student-aid accountability.
IHPC did not oppose accountability. Rather, it urged policymakers to distinguish among different measures of educational and financial performance. Repayment outcomes, early-career earnings, and long-term professional value are related—but they are not interchangeable measures.
IHPC argued that federal frameworks governing student-loan eligibility and program evaluation should give greater consideration to actual repayment and default performance rather than relying too heavily on early-career earnings measures that may not accurately predict longer-term outcomes in healthcare professions.
As implementation moves forward, the policy landscape has become considerably clearer.
Final regulations have been issued. New federal borrowing limits have taken effect. Litigation has challenged aspects of the Department’s implementation of the professional-degree provisions. Several concerns identified during the rulemaking process remain unresolved because they arise not simply from Department regulations, but from the underlying federal statute.
The discussion has therefore moved from what should the final rules say? to a different set of questions:
What can the Department still address? What may be resolved through litigation? And what will require Congress to act?
A New Financing Environment for Graduate and Professional Education
The first major change concerns how students finance graduate and professional education.
Beginning July 1, 2026, Graduate PLUS borrowing ended for new borrowers, subject to transition provisions for certain previously enrolled students. New annual and aggregate federal borrowing limits now apply.
Students in programs classified as professional degrees generally have access to higher federal borrowing limits than students in the graduate category. Professional students generally face annual limits of $50,000 and a $200,000 professional aggregate limit, while graduate students generally face lower annual and aggregate limits.
Those are not the only limits that matter.
The new law also establishes a $257,500 lifetime maximum on federal student borrowing. That lifetime limit includes federal loans previously received by the student for undergraduate, graduate, and professional education, including prior Graduate PLUS borrowing.
As a result, a student does not necessarily enter professional education with a fresh $200,000 of federal borrowing capacity.
A student who has already borrowed $75,000 during undergraduate education, for example, has already consumed $75,000 of the lifetime maximum. That prior borrowing does not necessarily reduce the separate $200,000 professional-program aggregate limit, but it does reduce the student’s remaining capacity under the $257,500 lifetime ceiling. The amount actually available is therefore governed by the interaction of the applicable annual, professional-program, and lifetime limits.
This distinction is particularly important because the new lifetime limit looks back at federal borrowing that occurred before the student entered the professional program. It does not make prior borrowing improper or impose a new liability on past loans. Rather, prior federal borrowing is counted when determining how much additional federal borrowing remains available.
The law provides transitional treatment for certain students who were already enrolled and borrowing before July 1, 2026. But for students subject to the new limits, prior undergraduate borrowing can materially affect the federal financing available for subsequent professional education.
That interaction deserves particular attention from institutions that offer undergraduate pathways leading into their own professional programs. An undergraduate pathway that requires greater student borrowing may leave a student with less federal capacity to finance the professional degree that follows.
For professional education more generally, classification in the higher borrowing category therefore does not necessarily mean that federal financing will cover the full cost of attendance.
Where federal financing falls short, students may increasingly need to rely on scholarships, institutional assistance, employment, family resources, or private credit. Private loans are generally subject to credit underwriting and may require a cosigner, and their rates, repayment provisions, and borrower protections may differ substantially from federal loans. Students in multiyear professional programs must also consider whether private financing will remain available throughout their education.
This raises an important question that extends well beyond student lending:
Could access to professional education become increasingly dependent on financial circumstances rather than educational qualifications?
The answer will vary by profession, institution, program cost, prior student borrowing, and student population. The effects should therefore be measured rather than assumed.
Nevertheless, greater dependence on private financing creates a foreseeable concern for educational access—and potentially for development of the healthcare workforce, including service to rural and underserved communities.

Download the infographic (PDF) — Policy status as of September 22, 2026
Professional-Degree Litigation: Important, but a Different Issue
A second issue involves which educational programs qualify for the higher professional-student borrowing limits.
A federal district court has preliminarily stayed portions of the Department’s additional requirements for determining professional-degree status. During the stay, the Department is administering an interim list of programs treated as awarding professional degrees. Chiropractic programs awarding the D.C. or D.C.M. are expressly included, along with a number of other health professions.
The Department has also made clear that most of the underlying federal student-loan changes are unaffected by the court order. The elimination of Graduate PLUS and the new annual and aggregate borrowing limits remain in effect while litigation over the professional-degree definition continues.
For the integrative health community, the litigation is important. Its potential effect should not be confused with the underlying borrowing limits themselves.
The litigation may affect which programs receive professional-degree treatment. It does not change the borrowing limits enacted by Congress.
For programs that obtain professional-degree status, another question therefore remains:
Are the statutory borrowing limits sufficient to finance the education required to enter the profession?
Chiropractic provides a useful example. It currently occupies a comparatively favorable position because the D.C. and D.C.M. are being treated as professional degrees. But even the higher professional borrowing limits may leave a financing gap depending upon an institution’s cost of attendance and an individual student’s previous federal borrowing.
Classification and financing adequacy are therefore related—but different—policy questions.
What Happened to IHPC’s Earnings Concerns?
A third issue concerns the federal earnings-accountability system.
IHPC’s May submission warned that a uniform early-career earnings measure could mischaracterize licensed health professions in which graduates may establish practices, develop patient populations over time, work in rural or underserved communities, or follow income trajectories different from conventional salaried employment.
The final STATS and Earnings Accountability framework, which takes effect July 1, 2027, implements statutory provisions linking continued Direct Loan eligibility to graduate earnings. The applicable benchmark varies according to factors including credential level, geography, field of study, and other regulatory requirements. A qualifying program that fails its applicable earnings benchmark in two of three years can lose Direct Loan eligibility.
There was progress on one issue important to IHPC: the final framework includes W-2 wages and positive self-employment earnings reported on Schedule SE.
An important concern remains.
IHPC recommended that strong cohort repayment performance be considered as a safeguard, or at least as evidence warranting additional review. The final framework did not provide the broad low-default-rate or repayment safe harbor IHPC sought.
The practical consequence is significant:
Strong repayment performance does not currently protect a program from the earnings test.
A program may have low student-loan defaults and strong repayment outcomes yet still lose Direct Loan eligibility if it fails the statutory earnings benchmark in two of three years.
That distinction goes to the heart of IHPC’s May submission: Does early-career income by itself provide an adequate measure of whether graduates can successfully support the educational debt they incurred—and of the longer-term value of their professional education?
For professions in which graduates establish independent practices, build patient populations over time, or serve communities where income may be lower, the question deserves continued examination.
What Can Be Addressed Administratively—and What Requires Congress?
The developments since May have also clarified an important distinction between administrative and legislative remedies.
The Department retains consequential responsibilities involving program classification, data methodology, field and geographic comparisons, earnings measurement, transparency, and correction of calculation errors.
Institutions therefore have reason to validate their program classifications, completion cohorts, earnings information, geographic placement, and applicable comparators. The statute also provides an appeal mechanism for programmatic median-earnings determinations, making data accuracy particularly important.
Several broader changes advocated by IHPC or its partners appear to require congressional action.
Those could include adjusting borrowing limits over time to account for inflation, changing the statutory earnings-measurement period to better recognize professions with delayed income development, or providing supplemental protection for programs that demonstrate strong loan repayment and healthcare-workforce value.
The distinction is important for effective advocacy:
Administrative advocacy should focus on matters the Department has authority to change. Legislative advocacy should address structural limitations written into federal law.
Litigation represents a third—and narrower—avenue. Courts can determine whether the Department has acted within the authority Congress provided, but judicial decisions generally cannot substitute a different policy for requirements Congress itself enacted.
Understanding which avenue applies to which problem is essential to developing realistic policy solutions.
The Larger Issue: Access to the Healthcare Workforce
Federal student-aid policy appropriately seeks to protect students and taxpayers from excessive debt and educational programs that produce poor outcomes.
Student-aid policy can also affect who has the financial ability to enter a healthcare profession.
The interaction between undergraduate and professional borrowing makes that question particularly important.
Students do not all arrive at professional school from the same financial starting point. Some may have completed lower-cost prerequisite pathways with relatively little federal debt. Others may have financed four-year undergraduate degrees largely through federal loans. Under the new lifetime borrowing ceiling, those different pathways can leave students with significantly different amounts of federal borrowing capacity when they enter the same professional program.
If federal financing then fails to cover the remaining cost of professional education, greater reliance on private credit may affect who is financially able to continue.
Similarly, if federal accountability relies heavily on early-career earnings, programs whose graduates build practices gradually or serve lower-income communities may experience different outcomes from programs whose graduates predominantly enter conventional salaried employment.
These are not predictions that particular programs will fail or that particular students will be unable to finance their education.
They are questions that should now be answered with evidence.
IHPC is therefore encouraging educational institutions to develop program-level information about financing gaps, prior undergraduate borrowing, repayment performance, graduate earnings, practice ownership, workforce placement, service in rural and underserved communities, and the time required for graduates to establish stable professional earnings.
Institutions should also stress-test their own educational pathways. Where an institution offers undergraduate programs that feed into a professional degree, it should understand not only the undergraduate cost and available Pell support, but how much federal borrowing students may consume before beginning professional education.
Such information can serve two purposes: helping individual institutions prepare for the new federal environment and creating the evidence needed to evaluate whether future administrative or legislative changes are warranted.
From Commenting on Rules to Building the Evidence for What Comes Next
IHPC’s May submission was part of the federal rulemaking process. The next phase requires a different approach.
Educational institutions must understand their own financing and accountability exposure. Professional organizations can document how graduates actually enter practice and serve communities. IHPC can help aggregate that evidence across professions, identify common policy concerns, pursue appropriate administrative remedies, and develop targeted legislative proposals where the Department lacks authority to act.
IHPC will also continue monitoring Department guidance and pending litigation because both may materially affect individual professions and educational programs.
The objective is not to weaken accountability.
It is to help ensure that federal accountability measures accurately identify poor outcomes while recognizing legitimate differences among professional educational pathways and avoiding unnecessary restrictions on access to the healthcare professions and communities the nation needs.
The policy details are complicated, but the underlying question is straightforward:
Can federal student-aid policy protect students and taxpayers while preserving equitable access to healthcare education and supporting a strong and diverse healthcare workforce?
IHPC believes that question deserves continued attention as the new federal framework is implemented.
Related Resources
IHPC Supplemental Comments on the Department of Education Proposed STATS Rule — May 18, 2026